Amish Country Popcorn Reviews
Amish Country Popcorn has an overall rating of 3.9 based on 47 reviews. Customer feedback on Amish Country Popcorn is mixed: Amish Country Popcorn reviewers highlight positive aspects like great taste, wide variety of flavors, excellent customer service, fast shipping, which strongly appeal to popcorn enthusiasts, health-conscious snackers, families looking for quality snacks. However, Amish Country Popcorn is often criticized for its higher price point, occasional shipping issues, limited international shipping, some flavors may not appeal to everyone.
47 reviews
5 Stars
8
4 Stars
4
3 Stars
3
2 Stars
2
1 Star
1
How would you rate Amish Country Popcorn?
All Amish Country Popcorn Reviews (47)
Robert-blakeney
May 21, 2026
"The popcorn didn’t taste very fresh to..."
The popcorn didn’t taste very fresh to me, kind of stale honestly. Not sure if anyone else had the same experience or if I just got an off batch...
0
Reply
Richard_mcdonald84
May 17, 2026
"My order came right on time again, just..."
My order came right on time again, just like they promised. Soo nice not having to wonder when it’ll arrive
0
Reply
hello_sylvia347
May 11, 2026
"Good popcorn, but not totally hull-free"
I bought this mostly because I was hoping it would mean fewer hulls getting stuck in my teeth. It definitely seems better than regular popcorn, though I keep wondering if I expected it to be completely hulless, which it isn’t. It pops up nicely and feels lighter to snack on. I did take off a star because a few pieces came out a little chewy, but overall I’d probably buy it again
0
Reply
ranaenicholson6518
April 17, 2026
"Seasoning is just right"
I tried a few of the popcorn seasonings from Amish Country Popcorn, they got the balance close to perfect.
It’s not overly salty or fake tasting, which I appreciated since some other brands seem like they’re just covering everything up with salt and artificial flavor. This one actually sticks to the popcorn well, too, so I didn’t have to use half the bottle just to taste it.
Ordering was simple, everything arrived fine, and the flavors were definitely better than the usual store-bought stuff I’ve been settling for.
It’s not overly salty or fake tasting, which I appreciated since some other brands seem like they’re just covering everything up with salt and artificial flavor. This one actually sticks to the popcorn well, too, so I didn’t have to use half the bottle just to taste it.
Ordering was simple, everything arrived fine, and the flavors were definitely better than the usual store-bought stuff I’ve been settling for.
0
Reply
Earnest_morris81
April 15, 2026
"It got here faster than I..."
It got here faster than I expected, so... yeah, really happy with the shipping. Thanks!
0
Reply
hello_bonnie340
April 12, 2026
"The popcorn showed up really well packed, and..."
The popcorn showed up really well packed, and everything was intact, nothing broken, spilled, or crushed. The bags were sealed tight, and the box held up fine during shipping. I was going to give it 5 stars, but, well, the only reason I’m going with 4 is there were some little cardboard bits or packing dust inside. Not a huge deal at all, just something I noticed. Overall, I’m happy with how it arrived...
0
Reply
dianamoore0029
March 30, 2026
"Fine for a Gift, I Think"
It’s nice, but smaller than I was expecting it to be. For gifting, okay it is, just not very big.
0
Reply
AudreyPhipps_14
March 01, 2026
"I liked the popcorn overall, the flavors were..."
I liked the popcorn overall, the flavors were good, and there were plenty of options to pick from. I did notice the main pattern was that the snacking part was way better than the waiting part, because delivery took longer than I expected. Not a bad experience at all, just more of an average one for me...
0
Reply
Georgia_yarbrough80
February 17, 2026
"Good Popcorn Overall, Just a Few Duds"
I’ve made two bags so far, and based on actually cooking them, they popped better than a lot of the store-brand popcorn I usually grab. There were still a few kernels left at the bottom of the pan, but it wasn’t enough to bother me.
The popcorn itself came out light, crunchy, and evenly cooked on the stovetop. It’s not totally perfect, but after trying it a couple of times, I’d say it’s good enough that I’d buy it again
The popcorn itself came out light, crunchy, and evenly cooked on the stovetop. It’s not totally perfect, but after trying it a couple of times, I’d say it’s good enough that I’d buy it again
0
Reply
charles.Zuniga
February 01, 2026
"I Didn’t Find Much That Interested Me"
I was hoping to find more options, but it all felt limited to me. I kept seeing the same kinds of items over and over, so there wasn’t much that really caught my eye.
0
Reply
Mamie-ruiz
January 20, 2026
"Pretty easy site to use"
The site was easy to navigate, and I found what I needed quickly.
0
Reply
JillStorey_07
January 17, 2026
"The popcorn itself was fine, but I was..."
The popcorn itself was fine, but I was disappointed by how hard it was to find clear ingredient and dietary information. If someone has allergies or specific food restrictions, that kind of info should be easy to access. It just doesn’t feel worth the risk for me, so I’m not sure I’d order again
0
Reply
Ruby_daugherty99
January 06, 2026
"Order was all there"
Everything I ordered showed up just like I picked it. No problems or missing items, so yeah, straightforward. I guess that’s really all I was hoping for...
0
Reply
irving_Thorngren03
December 26, 2025
"Helpful and quick to respond"
I had a question about my order and they got back to me fairly quickly. The reply was friendly and easy to understand, and I didn’t feel like I was being passed around. They took care of the issue the same day, which I really appreciated. I’d definitely feel comfortable recommending their service based on my experience.
0
Reply
anne_Slaughter04
December 23, 2025
"Reminds Me of Amish Country Popcorn"
I ordered the sampler and was really happy with it. The popcorn tasted fresh and brought back memories of the kind we used to pick up around Amish country. The website was easy to use, shipping was quick, and everything was simple from start to finish. Really grateful to have found this, I’ll definitely be ordering again.
0
Reply
richard2002
December 20, 2025
"I’ve tried a few different kinds from..."
I’ve tried a few different kinds from Amish Country Popcorn now, and the flavor has been really good every time. The kernels pop up nice and it tastes fresh, not like the bagged stuff from the store that all kinda ends up tasting the same, you know? Defintely not bland.
The mushroom popcorn has a nice full flavor, and the ladyfinger one is probably my favorite when I just want butter and salt. It’s simple, but it actually tastes like something, which I appriciate. I’ll be buying it again for sure.
The mushroom popcorn has a nice full flavor, and the ladyfinger one is probably my favorite when I just want butter and salt. It’s simple, but it actually tastes like something, which I appriciate. I’ll be buying it again for sure.
0
Reply
eleanor-Folkerts
December 15, 2025
"The popcorn itself was decent and tasted good..."
The popcorn itself was decent and tasted good, but it felt a bit overpriced for what you get. I was expecting better value based on how it was presented, but the reality didn’t really match the promise. Not bad, just not cheap enough to make me want to buy it often
0
Reply
kathleen1993
December 06, 2025
"I ordered a big bulk bag of..."
I ordered a big bulk bag of popcorn for our family movie nights, and once it finally showed up, everything was fine. The price was fair, it pops well, and I definitely like not having to reorder every other week. I was just frustrated with how long I had to wait for it to arrive
0
Reply
Have a question about Amish Country Popcorn?
Log in to ask your Amish Country Popcorn question!
Customer Reviews
Ask a Question
